A friend from work found these mini Pillow Pets at Dollar Tree. The store only gets one shipment of them a year and she bought all 114 of them. She sold them to friends and I bought 23 for Jack's class.
I had these clear plastic bags on hand from something similar. I slipped a Pillow Pet into each bag, tied it with some red ribbon leftover from Christmas, and attached a tag I made using Picmonkey. Super simple to do and only $1 a piece!
I just know the little kiddos are going to love them!